"The Dalton" was terrific! I can see why people might think their bread is "meh," but the panini style alleviates that problem :) Also, 1/2 is more than enough. Light eaters could share it.
Enormous sandwiches definitely worth waiting for. The line moves quick and there are plenty of sandwich and chip options to keep you distracted. Come for lunch and don't forget to get a beverage!
I had Jolly Olly, my husband had Lady Legg, and my son had the Greek. I had a bite of theirs and all 3 were delicious. I don't think you can make a bad choice in this place. Bread was good. Very busy